← All Insights
INSIGHTS / PERFORMANCE MANAGEMENT

Balanced Scorecard:
from strategy to results.

A new way to manage your business: measurable objectives, informed decisions and concrete actions.

E-project · In depth11-minute read

How to turn strategic objectives into measurable indicators, informed decisions and concrete actions. The role of Business Intelligence, reporting and Artificial Intelligence in performance management.

What is the Balanced Scorecard?

From measuring results to managing strategy

In an economic environment shaped by growing competition, digital transformation, technological innovation and rapid market changes, managing a company through financial indicators alone is no longer enough.

Revenue, profitability, EBITDA, margins and cash flows remain essential, but mainly reflect the outcomes of decisions already taken. They do not always explain which factors will determine the organisation’s future competitiveness.

The Balanced Scorecard (BSC) was developed to overcome this limitation.

Introduced in 1992 by Robert S. Kaplan, a Harvard Business School professor, and David P. Norton, a management consultant and researcher, in the renowned Harvard Business Review article The Balanced Scorecard—Measures That Drive Performance, it has become one of the best-known approaches to measuring and managing business performance.

Initially conceived as a multidimensional performance measurement system, the model gradually evolved into a Strategic Performance Management tool connecting vision, strategy, objectives, indicators and operational initiatives.

Kaplan and Norton explored this crucial transition in The Balanced Scorecard: Translating Strategy into Action (1996).

The principle is simple, yet revolutionary:

Measuring how much a company has earned is not enough. We need to understand why it achieved particular results and which conditions it must build today to sustain them tomorrow.

The four perspectives of the Balanced Scorecard

The classic model organises strategic objectives around four complementary perspectives.

The four perspectives of the Balanced Scorecard
PerspectiveStrategic questionExamples of KPIs
FinancialHow do we create sustainable economic value?EBITDA, margins, ROI, cash flow, revenue growth
Customers and marketsHow do customers perceive us, and how do we strengthen our competitiveness?Retention, satisfaction, market share, on-time delivery
Internal processesWhich processes must we excel at?Productivity, OEE, scrap, lead time, quality, operational efficiency
Learning and growthWhich skills and capabilities must we develop to improve?Skills, training, innovation, engagement, digital maturity

The four perspectives are not separate compartments: they represent interconnected dimensions of business strategy.

Investment in staff training, for example, can help improve production process quality. Better quality can reduce scrap and improve on-time delivery. Greater reliability can strengthen customer satisfaction and, over time, support revenue and margin growth.

The BSC represents these relationships as measurable, testable strategic hypotheses.

The Strategy Map: showing how value is created

One of the methodology’s most important developments is the Strategy Map, explored by Kaplan and Norton in Strategy Maps: Converting Intangible Assets into Tangible Outcomes (2004).

The strategy map visualises the expected relationships between objectives across the perspectives, clarifying how an organisation intends to create value.

For example, in a manufacturing company:

Skills development → Better production processes → Higher quality and more reliable delivery → Customer retention → Greater profitability.

These relationships should not automatically be treated as proven: they are management hypotheses to monitor and, wherever possible, test against data and evidence.

This connection is precisely what distinguishes the Balanced Scorecard from a traditional indicator dashboard.

A dashboard shows how particular activities are performing. A complete Balanced Scorecard connects performance to business strategy and the decisions needed to implement it.

Lagging and leading indicators

Another fundamental principle is the balance between two types of indicators.

Lagging indicators measure results already achieved: revenue, profit, margins, market share and customer churn.

Leading indicators measure factors that may anticipate or influence future results: order book quality, acquired skills, qualified sales opportunities, service levels and process stability.

A company monitoring only lagging indicators risks recognising a problem after it has already had financial consequences.

A well-designed Balanced Scorecard helps identify early signs of deteriorating or improving performance.

Why the Balanced Scorecard remains relevant

More than thirty years after its introduction, the Balanced Scorecard remains relevant because it addresses a widespread problem: the gap between stated strategy and everyday management.

Today, the methodology can be strengthened by tools unavailable in the 1990s: Data Analytics platforms, Business Intelligence, application integration, predictive analytics and Artificial Intelligence.

The growing focus on sustainability, digitalisation and human capital can also be incorporated into the BSC through objectives and indicators consistent with the organisation’s strategy.

The methodology’s value therefore lies not in a rigid set of four perspectives, but in its ability to build a balanced, adaptable management system focused on the long term.

Adoption of the Balanced Scorecard in Italy and Europe

An internationally established methodology

Over the past three decades, the Balanced Scorecard has been applied in private and public organisations, large industrial groups, service companies, healthcare institutions and public administrations.

Its adoption has been examined in numerous academic studies and management surveys.

A scientific review published in 2024 in Review of Managerial Science, entitled Balanced Scorecard: Trends, Developments, and Future Directions, highlights the breadth of the literature and the model’s evolution towards sustainability, strategic management, customer orientation and integrated performance systems.

When examining adoption, however, it is necessary to distinguish awareness of the concept from actual use of the model and the use of simple multidimensional dashboards.

There is no single, recent, statistically representative percentage describing BSC adoption across all Italian or European companies.

The Balanced Scorecard in Italy

In Italy, interest in the Balanced Scorecard developed mainly through studies of strategic control, planning and advanced performance measurement systems.

One of the first reference studies was conducted by Università Carlo Cattaneo – LIUC, under the academic coordination of Professor Alberto Bubbio.

The findings, presented in the 2004 article Diffusione della Balanced Scorecard in Italia: risultati di una ricerca ed evidenze empiriche, indicated that adoption was still relatively limited.

Of 250 companies contacted, 106 responded and 54 completed the questionnaire. Among the 106 respondents, approximately 18% reported using the Balanced Scorecard, while a further 8% expressed interest in the methodology.

The research focused mainly on large companies and was not a national census. These figures should therefore be interpreted as a historical snapshot of the sample, not as Italy’s current adoption rate.

Subsequent studies explored the organisational factors influencing BSC implementation.

Particularly significant is Lorenzo Lucianetti’s L'adozione della Balanced Scorecard: i risultati di una ricerca empirica, published in Management Control (2011), based on the experience of 103 organisations.

The research shows that the model’s effectiveness depends not only on adoption but also on how it is designed and used. A technically inadequate scorecard, or one disconnected from decision-making processes, may fail to deliver the expected benefits.

A further contribution is the study by Costantini, Landi and Bonazzi (2020), Factors Influencing the Use of the Balanced Scorecard: Evidence from a Regional Context in Italy, conducted in north-eastern Italy.

The study confirms a greater tendency towards adoption in larger companies, while highlighting an interesting finding: in manufacturing, smaller companies may also show interest in and a propensity to use the BSC.

This finding is particularly relevant to Italy’s business landscape, largely made up of industrial, commercial and service SMEs.

Adoption in Europe

In Europe, too, the Balanced Scorecard has gained an important place among strategic management methodologies, with adoption levels varying between countries, sectors and organisation types.

A quantitative reference is Bain & Company’s international Management Tools & Trends 2015 survey of 1,067 managers worldwide.

In the report, 44% of respondents from the EMEA region reported using the Balanced Scorecard.

Other studies have documented BSC applications in Germany, Austria, Switzerland, the United Kingdom, Portugal and the Nordic countries.

In Scandinavia in particular, the Balanced Scorecard has also been used in public administrations.

A 2019 study of the model’s adoption in Norwegian municipalities cites earlier surveys showing that approximately 56% of the municipal administrations examined used the BSC in 2015.

These results are not directly comparable with those for private companies, but demonstrate the model’s ability to adapt to organisations pursuing goals other than profit.

What the research tells us

The academic evidence suggests three observations.

First: the Balanced Scorecard is widely studied and applied across different organisational settings, but adoption varies considerably by sector and company size.

Second: simply introducing financial and non-financial KPIs does not guarantee effective strategic management. Consistent objectives, clear responsibilities and a real connection between indicators and decisions are essential.

Third: technology can make the BSC more accessible, timely and sustainable for small and medium-sized companies too, reducing the manual effort needed to update and distribute information.

Digitalisation supported by AI can therefore support adoption while keeping the quality of organisational design at the centre.

A practical example: the Balanced Scorecard in a manufacturing company

Consider a manufacturer seeking to increase profitability by improving quality, delivery reliability and production efficiency.

Management might set the strategic objective of increasing margins without compromising service quality.

The financial perspective would monitor EBITDA, contribution margin by product line and manufacturing costs.

The customer perspective would focus on on-time delivery, complaints, retention and new customer acquisition.

The internal process perspective could consider OEE, scrap rate, throughput times and productivity.

The learning and growth perspective could monitor technical skills, training effectiveness, innovation capabilities and the digital maturity of processes.

The Balanced Scorecard would make it possible to observe not only the final financial result but also the evolution of the operational and organisational factors that may influence it.

With Business Intelligence, managers could explore data by plant, department, production line, customer or product.

With automated reporting, indicators could be distributed regularly without manually rebuilding the analyses.

With contextual AI, management could query the available data to identify anomalies and develop hypotheses about the possible causes of variances.

Strategy would thus become an observable, shared management model that can be updated over time.

This example is illustrative: indicators, targets and architecture must be defined around the company’s specific circumstances.

Expected benefits for businesses

A well-designed Balanced Scorecard can deliver benefits beyond improved reporting.

Strategic alignment. Executives and managers share objectives, priorities and reference indicators, reducing the risk of individual functions optimising local results at the expense of overall goals.

Greater ability to anticipate change. Leading indicators identify conditions that may influence future performance, complementing traditional financial measures.

More informed decisions. Consistent, timely information makes it easier to analyse variances and define corrective actions.

Clearer accountability. KPIs, targets and initiatives are assigned to designated owners, clarifying the contribution of different organisational areas.

Less manual work. Digitalising data collection, processing and distribution can free up time currently spent preparing information.

Continuity between strategy and operations. Budgets, results, improvement initiatives and strategic reviews can be managed within a unified model.

Actual benefits depend on design quality, data reliability, management involvement and the organisation’s ability to embed the system sustainably.

Conclusion: from understanding results to shaping them

The Balanced Scorecard represents a fundamental evolution in management control: from simply monitoring results to managing the factors that help determine them in an integrated way.

Academic research and practical experience show that its value depends not on the number of available indicators, but on the ability to translate strategy into a coherent system of objectives, measures, responsibilities and initiatives.

Today, Business Intelligence, automation and Artificial Intelligence can make this methodology more dynamic, accessible and integrated into everyday management.

Because the real goal is not to produce more indicators.

It is to understand the business better, identify priorities early and make better decisions.

Bibliographic and academic references

Kaplan, R. S., Norton, D. P. (1992). The Balanced Scorecard—Measures That Drive Performance. Harvard Business Review, January–February 1992, pp. 71–79. Harvard Business Review.

Kaplan, R. S., Norton, D. P. (1996). The Balanced Scorecard: Translating Strategy into Action. Harvard Business School Press, Boston.

Kaplan, R. S., Norton, D. P. (2004). Strategy Maps: Converting Intangible Assets into Tangible Outcomes. Harvard Business School Press, Boston.

Bubbio, A., Baraldi, S., Bocci, F. (2004). Diffusione della Balanced Scorecard in Italia: risultati di una ricerca ed evidenze empiriche. Controllo di Gestione, n. 6/2004. Read the study.

Lucianetti, L. (2011). L'adozione della Balanced Scorecard: i risultati di una ricerca empirica. Management Control, n. 3/2011, pp. 39–66. DOI: 10.3280/MACO2011-003003.

Costantini, A., Landi, S., Bonazzi, M. (2020). Factors Influencing the Use of the Balanced Scorecard: Evidence from a Regional Context in Italy. International Journal of Academic Research in Business and Social Sciences. University research.

Bain & Company (2015). Management Tools & Trends 2015. International survey on the use of management tools. Bain report.

Kumar, S., Lim, W. M., Sureka, R., Jabbour, C. J. C., Bamel, U. (2024). Balanced Scorecard: Trends, Developments, and Future Directions. Review of Managerial Science, 18, pp. 2397–2439. DOI: 10.1007/s11846-023-00700-6.

Madsen, D. Ø. et al. (2019). The Diffusion and Implementation of the Balanced Scorecard in the Norwegian Municipality Sector: A Descriptive Analysis. Social Sciences, 8(5), 152. Scientific study.

From methodology to implementation.

Discover how E-project helps companies build a digital Balanced Scorecard.

Discover the E-project approach